Cui Bono? Another Contrived Controversy

This week Volusia County District 3 Councilman Danny Robins saw the self-serving need to wade into the latest skirmish in the “Culture Wars” when he voiced support for an ‘alternative country’ artist named Jason Aldean, who released a song some have used to stoke yet another contrived controversy.  

I’ve never heard Mr. Aldean’s music.

Don’t hold that against me.

I grew up on old Hank Williams, Patsy Cline, Merle Haggard, Guy Clark, George Jones, and Earnest Tubb – which means I abhor the alternative

According to an article by Sheldon Gardner writing in The Daytona Beach News-Journal, last Friday, Councilman Robins posted his support for Aldean on social media after fiery criticism of his recent release “Try That in a Small Town” – a contrived product, no doubt composed by a writers consortium, recorded over an electronic drum loop, packaged by a marketing team, and sung by a young man who is carefully dressed, coiffed, hatted, and presented by a record company’s image group – then consumed by millions of young people who have no concept of what ‘country music’ was. 

That’s why they call it the ‘Music Business.’

Because everyone is offended by everything these days, self-absorbed culture warriors on both sides of the divide, seized on the opportunity for a Summer of ‘23 brouhaha (as though it wasn’t annoyingly hot enough already) – with those on the “left” claiming the tune represents racist dog whistle – while those on the “right” defend it as “God, Guns, and Apple Pie” patriotism.

The fact is, it’s neither.

For the uninitiated, we live in a shameless age where any publicity is considered good publicity, and I have no doubt this latest sociopolitical tempest in a teapot was carefully crafted by Mr. Aldean’s record label and management team ahead of his 39 city “Highway Desperado” tour which began July 14. 

They should send Mr. Robins a thank you note for helping perpetuate the horseshit and hype…

Look, I haven’t listened to the song – but I read the lyrics to “Try That in a Small Town,” and, in my view, there is nothing overtly racist about it.  (Although the “coincidence” wasn’t lost on me that the accompanying overproduced music video was filmed at the infamous Maury County Courthouse in Columbia, Tennessee, where an 18-year-old African-American was brutally lynched in 1927…)

According to Aldean’s detractors, the song is a call for racial vigilantism – full of triggering tropes and emotional hot buttons like lawless riots, anti-police rhetoric, gun confiscation, looting, violent crime, and “anti-American” behavior – something the self-promoting Councilman Robins took full advantage of when he grabbed on to Aldean’s coattails. 

According to the News-Journal, “Robins added that the music video contains images or clips that were real, and that Aldean “refuses to sit back and be quiet anymore.”

“He refuses to be silenced, he stands by his values and not afraid of backlash and he’s got a pair. If some people don’t like it, o well. Their thin-skinned interpretation, feelings and opinions don’t change the facts,” Robins wrote. “As far as I am concerned he is a good man and we need more people like him. I stand by my public support.”

Congratulations, Councilman Robins, like a swooning teenybopper, you bought the marketing strategy – hook, line, and sinker…

Whatever.

Hey, Danny – Word to the wise:  It was a business decision

Get it? 

My God, how heartbreaking. I feel like I’m telling Mr. Robins the Easter Bunny isn’t real…

Whenever I read about one of these engineered controversies, I always ask myself “Cui Bono?”

To whom is it a benefit?

Media and entertainment companies – especially social media – have a vested interest in stirring controversy because they profit from the audience it drives, politicians gain notoriety when they get their name in the paper, and professional crybaby’s benefit from their next 15-minutes of victimhood…

It is similar to how both political parties work to divide voters with increasingly outlandish “Us vs. Them” rhetoric – fostering conflict and creating a distraction to better serve those special interests who feed the machine with massive campaign contributions – rather than find common ground and compromise on those issues important to all citizens.   

In my view, it is time citizens (and our political leadership) come to the realization that patriotism isn’t a beer brand – and it damn sure has nothing to do with another cultural controversy designed, subliminally or on purpose, to exploit our differences – and provide another forum for the fringe elements to fan the flames of divisiveness and controversy as a means of pushing an agenda.

Or selling concert tickets…

In my view, We, The Little People are being manipulated by forces, internal and external, intent on destroying the United States of America without ever firing a shot – and when those elected officials we expect to demonstrate strong leadership engage in gross political grandstanding by wallowing in the muck of another manufactured controversy – it fans the flames of conflict, legitimizes polarization, and pushes us ever closer to the goal of those who seek to divide and conquer.

It is time that citizens recognize this tripe for what it is.

Trust me.  We have enough issues right here in Volusia County to keep Mr. Robins and his “colleagues” on the dais of power in DeLand busy for the foreseeable future – real problems – like our inadequate transportation infrastructure, overdevelopment, traffic congestion, dwindling water quality in our lakes, rivers, and springs, devastating flooding, disastrously low wages contributing to a workforce housing crisis, gross mismanagement and distrust in County government, our dwindling quality of life, coastal erosion, rising taxes and fees, and the myriad other civic, social, and economic issues that are wholly ignored, or kicked down the dusty political trail, by these dullards we elect to serve our interests. 

In my view, as Mr. Aldean sells out arenas and cashes massive checks thanks to his carefully developed notoriety – it is time for Mr. Robins and others to stop the political showboating and focus on the issues important to the lives and livelihoods of long-suffering Volusia County residents.

16 thoughts on “Cui Bono? Another Contrived Controversy

  1. Simply reading the lyrics doesn’t cut it. Combined with the setting for the video and the images in the video, it is overtly racist. To post on it without looking at the entire presentation is disingenuous at best.

    Like

      1. This is Farcebook- or Twitter*-level discourse—kinda surprised to see it pass muster here

        *yes I refuse to call it “X”

        Like

  2. I haven’t heard the song either. But tons of my Republican friends on Facebook have posted “I stand with Jason Andean” and other positive comments about his song. The only thing I’ve seen so far, which was posted by a black singer I don’t know (hey, I’m an old woman and I tend to listen to the oldies) who stated he listened to the song and it was NOT racist. That’s all I know about the song (and I’m tired of it popping up on my feed).

    Yes, it would be nice if our government would pay attention to important issues like our infrastructure etc., rather than this garbage, but what do we expect? Really? Ugh!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Lori this family became non affiliated registered voters. Hope you don’t put us in a catagory.Shame when the time has come to say who your friends are by what party they belong to.The internet destroyed the human brain

      Like

  3. Amen Mark, Pretty sure the people who voted for him didn’t sign up for such nonsense. One would expect Robbins to have a bit more class and just do what we pay him for.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. You didn’t take Danny to the woodshed, you ran his little pint sized self into one of his bat houses!

    Like

  5. Mark, you have never been more on point. All of this is just what I have been thinking. I wish I could put my thoughts into words as eloquently as you do. The messages you are delivering here goes far beyond Danny Robins and his attention grabbing juvenile bs. I hope our fellow citizens will start coming to some realization about the current two party system and what we have become as a society. THANK YOU!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Freedom of speech.Would never let kids hear those lyrics.My neighbors 4 yr old started singing a rap song with four letter words.On my way to Ft.Lauderdale Beach for some good food and nightlife not like Razzles or the other shit on the beach in Daytona.Start worrying about the crowd in Daytona.We don’t go to Daytona Beach anymore

    Like

  7. Peter, I guess I should re-word my response. I have friends from both parties (republicans and democrats) and in this divisive time, many make comments about certain issues and people.
    Regarding this song, however, only republicans have said they “stood with” the singer…. And I still haven’t heard the song, nor do I plan to as I listen to 70’s on Sirius Radio 7. I saw one post about it previously mentioned.
    Hopefully this clarifies my prior comment.

    Like

    1. Lori please don’t forget those who watched the clown show this afternoon.Love that judge.We are not puppets.Have a great night.

      Like

  8. The county powers are under the thumb of the developer/real estate/ automobile sales conglomerate. They have been since the Great Depression. They can’t help themselves. Robbins is just part of it. I find it interesting that people decry the overdevelopment of our county and vote for the same old politicians.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Oh no! Say it ain’t so! Do you mean that we’re being …(GASP)… manipulated?!
    Why, how could they POSSIBLY do that to to such an alert, well-educated citizenry? 😂

    Like

Leave a reply to ted hordecky Cancel reply